Direct evidence

What UAH & Huntsville Knew

This page collects, in one place, the documented record of what the University of Alabama in Huntsville, the UA System Board of Trustees, Madison County, and the City of Huntsville knew — and when — about the former Jones/Avalon plantation land beneath campus and the Willie and Lola Jones homestead on Athens Pike. Every row below is drawn from a named source. Where the record is contested, both sides are shown.

Why this page exists. "Institutional erasure" is easy to assert and hard to prove. This page exists to make the underlying evidence checkable: dates, documents, and direct quotations, laid out as a timeline and an evidence table rather than folded into narrative prose. This material also appears within The Argument section of the home page; it is repeated here as a stand-alone, citable reference. A note on naming: "Avalon" is a retrospective label (per a 1968–71 Harrison family history), not the plantation's documented period name.

Direct answer or finding

The record indicates that both UAH and the City of Huntsville/Madison County were direct parties to land transactions on the parcel now disputed by the Willie and Lola Jones family, and that UAH's own newsroom has published the deed and condemnation history for that parcel. The record also indicates the university has taken an official public position — that the Jones family was compensated and that neither the Board of Trustees nor UAH ever acquired the land directly from the family — while the family disputes the acreage figure and alleges the 1958 deed bearing Willie Jones's signature was forged. Additional documentation, specifically the complete original condemnation and payment file, is needed before the acreage and forgery questions can be resolved by an independent party rather than by either side's own account.

Evidence table

Confidence levels: Documented = directly stated in a primary or institutional source below; Disputed = the two named parties give conflicting accounts; Inferential = a reasonable connection drawn between two documented facts, not itself directly stated in a single source. The earlier rows (1792–1848) establish the Jones family and land history the later institutional record rests on; the 1966–71 rows document the institutional paper trail for the campus footprint.
* The 1792 marriage entry rests on register OCR and indexer reads — the image tiles failed to render, so the handwriting has not been visually verified.

Date	Person(s) / Party	Place	Record Type	Key Detail	Source	Confidence
Oct. 22, 1792	Llewellin Jones; Mary Anderson (daughter of Nelson Anderson, who gave consent)	Louisa County, Virginia	Marriage register entry	"Llewellin Jones" to "Mary Anderson," October 22, 1792; surety Alexander Anderson; witnesses Martin Baker and Andrew Thomson. Confirmed from the primary record. (This is not the Mary Anderson of the colonial-era correspondence — a different woman.)	Register of marriages, Louisa County, Virginia, 1766–1861, DGS 007578998 (film 32190), image 61 of 527	Documented from the primary record — handwriting not yet visually verified*
Dec. 20, 1823	Alabama Legislature	Alabama (state)	Statute	"An Act To establish the Bank of the State of Alabama," sec. 2: university-land money vested as bank capital "shall not exceed one hundred thousand dollars" — a statutory cap, not a balance. This cap, not a fund balance, is the origin of the repeated "$100,000 University Fund" figure.	Alabama bank charter act, approved Dec. 20, 1823	Documented
1825	Gov. Israel Pickens; Alabama State Treasury	Alabama (state)	Legislative message + treasury ledger	Two transfers "as capital stock of the Bank": $48,058.45 (Jan. 17, 1825) + $8,554.49¼ (Mar. 1, 1825) = exactly $56,612.94¼, bearing 6% interest payable semi-annually — the verified University Fund balance. Triple-corroborated: Pickens's Nov. 21, 1825 farewell message, the ADAH/Alabama Legislature transcription of the Nov. 22, 1825 evening session, and the ADAH treasury ledger, University Fund account (ledger p. 5).	Journal of the House of Representatives of the State of Alabama, 7th annual session (1826), 10; ADAH State Treasury ledger, University Fund account	Documented
Jan. 13, 1827	Alabama Legislature	Alabama (state)	Joint resolution	The 1823 $100,000 cap on university-land money vested as bank capital is removed — the statutory ceiling that had been repeated as though it were the fund's balance no longer applied.	Joint resolution, approved Jan. 13, 1827	Documented
Jan. 1829	Alabama State Treasury	Alabama (state)	Treasury ledger	The University Fund stands at $128,654.36¼ (certified Nov. 1831), with $46,475.47 more transferred in 1831 — the fund demonstrably exceeded the supposed $100,000 figure. A projection converted to fact, then a cap repeated as a balance.	ADAH State Treasury ledger, University Fund account (ledger p. 5)	Documented
May 1, 1842	Elizabeth Berry (writing as "Elizabeth Berry or Jones")	Jackson County, Alabama	Letter	Written from Jackson County; asks S. G. Berry to come or send money to pay a judgment of about $30, and asks Abe Hunter to send tobacco "by Jim when he comes in" — diary/correspondence-class material. Filed as an exhibit in the Berry chancery case.	Project research databases (DB1 1454; DB4 564; paper note [386])	Documented
1844–48	Dearing v. Lightfoot — parties and deponents, Lawrence County Circuit Court	Moulton, Lawrence County, Alabama	Chancery/detinue suit	Detinue suit over six enslaved people — Hercules (alias Harceles, ~10) and Solomon (~20), each mortgaged at $2,000 in 1840, plus Aggy, Edward, Tilla, and Fenton — whose testimony traces Georgia to western Tennessee to north Alabama. Names enslaved people directly.	Project research databases (DB1 1392; DB4 563; paper note [382])	Documented
1866–68	Huntsville deed parties	Huntsville, Alabama	Deed records	Post-war Huntsville deed records documenting transfers in the city — part of the documented property chain behind the twentieth-century campus footprint. Selected records held in the project archive; full analysis pending.	Project archive; research databases	Documented (records held; analysis pending)
1966–67	UAH campus development records	Huntsville, Alabama	Easement correspondence	UAH easement correspondence from the campus-development period — institutional-records texture for how the campus footprint was assembled, in the years immediately before UAH's 1969 founding. Held in the project archive; full analysis pending.	Project archive	Documented (records held; analysis pending)
1971	Swartz Property deed memorandum	Huntsville, Alabama	Memorandum with certified deed copy	A 1971 memorandum containing a certified copy of the Swartz Property deed for the first portion of the UAH campus — the strongest new documentary link in the Avalon-to-UAH land chain. Held in the project archive; the underlying chain's full analysis pending.	Project archive; research notes (new evidence review, Sept. 2026)	Documented (record held; analysis pending)
July 1, 1954	Huntsville City Council; new waterworks utility board	Huntsville, Alabama	Institutional history (cited)	The city hands its municipal water system to a new waterworks utility board because "[t]he source of supply was polluted and inadequate to meet the demands of growth at the dawning of the space age." The well condemnation is authorized one month later — inside a documented municipal water crisis.	Patrick McCauley, "The Origins of Huntsville's Waterworks Utility Board," Huntsville Historical Review 25(1), Jan. 1998 (PDF)	Documented
1954	Willie Fay Jones and family; City of Huntsville	Athens Pike (now Holmes Ave.), Huntsville	Condemnation proceeding	The City of Huntsville condemns a 60-by-40-foot well-site parcel (Probate Cause No. 12257; Council Resolutions 54-109 and 54-127). The Probate Court's initial compensation award is $900 (Dec. 30, 1954) — not, as the family remembers, a pre-condemnation purchase offer. A circuit-court jury raises it to $1,250 on appeal (Nov. 7, 1955). "Declaring the water unfit" is the family's/news account; the official record's stated purpose is securing a clean public water supply — no health or inspection order has been located.	WHNT News 19, 2023; UAH Athens Pike timeline; UAH Athens Pike documents	Documented (competing accounts of the rationale, attributed)
Oct. 15, 1958	Willie & Lola Mae Jones; W. L. Sanderson Realty	Athens Pike, Huntsville	Warranty deed	Two tracts, including a 2.25-acre parcel, conveyed to a realty company headed by the City of Huntsville's own land-acquisition chief. Willie Jones's surviving children say their father was illiterate, always signed with an "X," and that this signature was forged.	UAH Athens Pike documents; WHNT News 19, 2023	Disputed
1962–64	Sanderson family; Board of Trustees of the University of Alabama; several Jones heirs	Athens Pike, Huntsville	Deed + condemnation proceeding + equity suit	The Sandersons convey the 2.25-acre tract to the Board of Trustees (Apr. 6, 1962). A second condemnation the same year (Probate Cause No. 14431), "for public use" and to donate property to the University of Alabama "for educational purposes" — the July 11, 1962 hearing minutes state the purpose as donation to the University "as a location for the Research Institute of Alabama" — compensates several Jones heirs and the Board itself for fractional interests in the same tract. In Equity Cause No. 18604, the Board of Trustees filed a cross-complaint as a partial owner (Dec. 13, 1963) and was awarded a 1/8 interest ($646.02) in the Feb. 27, 1964 final decree — meaning the Board was a documented litigant in the condemnation of the Jones land, holding a legal interest in the parcel before UAH was chartered. That sits in tension with UAH's Feb. 2025 statement (below) that "neither the UA System Board of Trustees nor UAH acquired the property from the Jones family" — true only through the Sanderson intermediary.	UAH Athens Pike timeline; UAH Athens Pike documents	Documented
June 1966	UAH campus planning office	UAH campus, Huntsville	Topographic survey map	A dated campus topographic map shows the university's property boundary already enclosing the stretch of the Athens Pike / Holmes Avenue corridor where the Jones homestead sat — three years before UAH's 1969 founding, and while planning and land-acquisition activity for the campus was actively underway.	Personal copy, 1966 UAH topographic map; see The Argument	Documented
c. mid-1960s (undated)	G. W. Jones and Sons (engineering firm); UAH Board of Trustees correspondence	Holmes Avenue, Huntsville	Engineering plan-and-profile sheets	Undated road-construction plan sheets trace the exact Athens Pike / Holmes Avenue corridor central to the Jones dispute, filed alongside UAH Board of Trustees correspondence — physical, contemporaneous evidence of the infrastructure work the family says displaced them.	Project archive, cross-referenced with 1966 topo map above	Inferential
1969–present	University of Alabama in Huntsville; Willie Jones's descendants	UAH campus (Business Administration Building site)	Institutional founding / land use	UAH is founded in 1969 on land including the former Jones property. The family maintains the true acreage taken was closer to 10–12 acres, against UAH's public record of 2.25 acres — a discrepancy that remains unresolved.	Where Is My Land, 2023	Disputed
Nov. 10, 2020	Drew Adan (UAH Archives); Alabama Historical Association	Huntsville, Alabama (public presentation transcript)	Institutional public narrative	Transcript of "The Avalon Plantation Marker Story" repeats claims this project's research has since corrected: that "Eliza Jones and her three biracial children" were manumitted on Lewellen Jones's 1820 death; that Shandy was "one of only 500 freemen" in 1850; and that Reuben Jones was Shandy's "halfbrother." Kept here as an exhibit of what the institutional narrative was — not as fact.	AHA transcript (PDF)	Documented (institutional position; contradicted by project research)
Nov. 2023	Where Is My Land (national advocacy org); Jones family	Huntsville, Alabama	Public press statement	The family and Where Is My Land publicly announce the claim, describing part of the disputed land as "currently being used as a parking lot" by UAH, and call for reparative justice.	Where Is My Land, Nov. 2023	Documented
Apr. 2024	Adolph Jones (grandson of Willie Jones); Huntsville City Council	Huntsville, Alabama	Public council testimony / news report	The family formally asks the city council for an independent review and restitution, stating they know they will not get the land itself back but want accountability.	AL.com, Apr. 2024	Documented
Feb. 13, 2025	University of Alabama in Huntsville (official statement)	Huntsville, Alabama	Institutional public statement	UAH states on the record that "public records ... indicate Mr. Jones and his immediate family, with the aid of legal counsel, were compensated for their interests in the property," and that "neither the UA System Board of Trustees nor UAH acquired the property from the Jones family."	WHNT News 19, Feb. 2025	Documented (institutional position)
2023–present	The Matthews family (lead)	Huntsville, Alabama	Public land-claim reporting	A second family, the Matthews, is pursuing parallel historical land-theft claims tied to UAH development. This is a lead, not a verified entry: a full dossier is under investigation, and nothing in this row should be treated as established fact.	herehuntsville.com	Lead (under investigation)

The condemnation paper trail, document by document

The sequence below is reconstructed from the deed and court documents published in UAH's own newsroom ("RE: THE JONES CLAIM TO THE ATHENS PIKE 2.25 ACRE LAND PARCEL," uah.edu/newsroom/athens-pike, with its documents page); UAH states the underlying records are publicly available at the Madison County Records Center and the Madison County Probate Court. One framing correction first: the condemned well is not on the Avalon plantation core. It is the Willie (Fay) Jones family well on a 2.25-acre parcel on the north margin of Athens Pike (now Holmes Avenue), about three miles northwest of Huntsville — the same Athens Pike orbit as the plantation lands. Willie and Lola Jones now connect genealogically to the Avalon-era Jones family through documented lineage: Willie Faye Jones (d. Nov. 1971) — the same man as the well-case litigant Willie Fay Jones — was the great-grandson of Columbus Jones and of Reuben Jones (see Gaps and cautions); only the claimed Shandy Wesley Jones link remains open and testable.

Aug. 12, 1954 — Huntsville City Council Resolution No. 54-109: authorizes the City to attempt to purchase a 60-by-40-foot parcel including the well site "for the purpose of securing a water supply sufficient for the inhabitants of the City of Huntsville."
Oct. 14, 1954 — Resolution No. 54-127: purchase attempt failed; the Council authorizes condemnation in the name of the City of Huntsville.
Oct. 22, 1954 — Verified Application, Probate Cause No. 12257, naming Willie Fay Jones and family among the potential claimants; the Oct. 25 service receipt describes "a lot 40 feet east and west and 60 feet north and south … together with the well located on said real estate."
Nov. 24, 1954 — Order of Condemnation (the family's attorney, David R. Archer, present; no objections made); Dec. 30, 1954 — Decree: three court-appointed jurors value the well site at $900; title vests in the City.
Jan. 24, 1955 — Notice of Appeal (Willie Fay Jones, Charlie Eldridge, Lloyd Jones, Reva Jones Boyd); Nov. 7, 1955 — Circuit Court Cause No. 6147: a jury raises the award to $1,250.
Dec. 21, 1955 — Affidavit of Willie Fay Jones, tracing the 2.25-acre parcel's succession from his grandmother Lizzie Jones; Rachelle Stewart witnessed his mark — a same-era mark signature that exists in the court file for comparison with the disputed 1958 deed.
Oct. 15, 1958 — Warranty Deed: Willie and Lola Mae Jones → W. L. Sanderson Realty (two tracts including the 2.25-acre parcel, minus the condemned well lot). The family alleges the signature was forged (reported in news coverage; see Eminent Domain); no handwriting analysis or court finding has been located.
Apr. 6, 1962 — Warranty Deed: the Sandersons convey the tract to the Board of Trustees of the University of Alabama.
June 11, 1962 — Condemnation Application, Probate Cause No. 14431 (Madison County and the City of Huntsville), "for public use" and to donate property to the University of Alabama "for educational purposes"; July 11, 1962 hearing minutes state the purpose as donation to the University "as a location for the Research Institute of Alabama."
Dec. 1962–Jan. 1963: the County and the City each deed their half-interests to the Board of Trustees.
Nov. 18, 1963 — Original Bill, Equity Cause No. 18604 (Jones heirs claim compensation); Dec. 13, 1963 — the Board of Trustees files a cross-complaint as a partial owner via the Sanderson deeds; Feb. 27, 1964 — Final Decree awards fractional interests: Lloyd Jones, Reba Jones Boyd, and Lillie Mae Crawford 1/8 each; the UA Board of Trustees 1/8 ($646.02); Charlie Eldridge and Neal Collier (or unknown heirs) 1/4 each.

Read against this record, UAH's February 2025 statement that "neither the UA System Board of Trustees nor UAH acquired the property from the Jones family" is true only through the Sanderson intermediary: the Board's 1962 deed came from Sanderson Realty, and its 1963–64 court filings recite the Jones → Sanderson (1958) → Board (1962) chain and take compensation as a Jones-land litigant. The county joins only the 1962 second condemnation; the 1954 taking was the City's. And no located document shows 1950s–60s officials referencing the land's plantation or slavery history — the 1962 condemnation's 60-year notice window (back to about 1902) would not have reached the plantation era in a title search, so no claim of contemporaneous plantation-knowledge can be made on current sources.

Interpretation

Read end to end, this timeline shows an institution that was a documented legal party to the land — receiving deeds, appearing in condemnation filings, and holding fractional interests years before its own 1969 founding — and that today controls the public narrative about how that land was acquired. That is not, by itself, evidence of wrongdoing; property does routinely change hands through condemnation, realty intermediaries, and heir settlements. What it does establish is that UAH and the Board of Trustees were positioned close enough to these transactions, early enough, that "the university had no direct dealings with the Jones family" is a narrower and more careful claim than "the university's predecessor entities and land-acquisition network had no knowledge of, or connection to, the disputed transfer." The 1966 topographic map and the undated Holmes Avenue engineering sheets matter here specifically because they show planning and infrastructure activity already underway over this exact corridor before or around the disputed period — contemporaneous documentation, not retrospective claim.

This case sits inside the same pattern this project documents at Avalon a century earlier: land and paperwork move cleanly through institutions and the parties who control filing and indexing, while the people losing land are left to reconstruct their own history from family memory, oral testimony, and whatever fragments of the record survive. Sociologically, this is Jeffrey Olick's mnemonic hegemony operating in real time rather than in the archival past: UAH's newsroom can publish "the documents" as an authoritative timeline precisely because it holds the documents, while the family's account of a forged signature and a larger stolen acreage has no equivalent institutional platform. It is also a live instance of what W. E. B. Du Bois called a "Propaganda of History" — not necessarily a fabrication, but a cleaner, institution-favoring account built from the records the institution chose to keep and publish.

Gaps and cautions

The forgery allegation is unresolved. No handwriting analysis, court finding, or independent document examination of the 1958 deed signature has been located (reported in news coverage; see Eminent Domain). The claim that Willie Jones signed with an "X" elsewhere, and could not have signed this deed, comes from family testimony reported by WHNT News 19 — a strong lead, not a proven fact. A December 21, 1955 court-file affidavit notes Rachelle Stewart witnessed Willie Jones's mark — a same-era mark signature that could be compared against the 1958 deed signature.

The acreage discrepancy (2.25 acres vs. 10–12 acres) is unresolved. Both figures come from named, citable sources, but we have not independently verified either against the original survey plats.

We have not located the complete original condemnation and payment file — only the excerpted timeline UAH has published and the family's public statements. A full independent review, which the family and Where Is My Land have publicly requested, has not yet occurred as far as this project can document.

The Willie Jones identity is resolved; the Shandy Wesley Jones link is not. The former open-and-testable question is now closed: the well-case litigant Willie Fay Jones (d. Nov. 1971) is the same man as Willie Faye Jones, grantor of the October 15, 1958 deed to W. L. Sanderson Realty (Madison County Deed Book 265, p. 314) — the November 18, 1963 bill in Equity Cause No. 18604 names the litigant as the grantor, and Hoksbergen & DeNeefe identify the deed and give his lineage (Alabama Review 79(3) (2026): 224–226, fns 116–118): his father Thomas Lee Jones was the grandson of Columbus and Tomietta Jones, and his mother Ruby Odell McCalley Jones was the granddaughter of Reuben and Jane Jones — making Willie the great-grandson of both Columbus and Reuben Jones, and the well condemnation the documented twentieth-century endpoint of the Avalon Jones family's own landholding. (This item previously fenced the two names as a do-not-merge lead; the documentation has since closed it — the former caution is preserved here for provenance.) What remains open: any documented link between Willie and Lola Jones and Shandy Wesley Jones, which is still unproven.

The G. W. Jones and Sons engineering sheets are undated beyond an approximate mid-1960s estimate based on the correspondence they were filed with; an archival date range should be confirmed with the repository before this evidence is treated as more than circumstantial.

The Oct. 22, 1792 marriage entry rests on register OCR and indexer reads. The image tiles for DGS 007578998, image 61, failed to render, so the handwriting has not been visually verified. The marriage is confirmed from the primary record; the visual read is still owed.

Full analysis is pending for the newly documented institutional records — the 1971 Swartz Property deed memo, the 1966–67 UAH easement correspondence, and the 1866–68 Huntsville deed records. Their existence is documented in the project archive; the interpretation above is provisional until the complete files are read.

Next research steps

Request the complete 1954 and 1962 Madison County condemnation case files (Madison County Probate Court / Circuit Court records) rather than relying on UAH's excerpted publication of them.

Seek an independent forensic or archival handwriting comparison of the 1958 warranty deed signature against other known Willie Jones signatures/marks in the public record — including the Dec. 21, 1955 court-file affidavit witnessed by Rachelle Stewart.

Locate the original 1958 survey plat to check the 2.25-acre figure against the family's 10–12-acre estimate.

Confirm the exact date and provenance of the G. W. Jones and Sons Holmes Avenue plan-and-profile sheets with the holding archive.

Search Madison County Probate Court deed and will indexes for further documentation of the Willie and Lola Jones household's place in the Columbus/Reuben Jones family lines — including the full December 21, 1955 affidavit (to identify "grandmother Lizzie Jones") and Deed Book 265, p. 314 itself. The Willie Fay/Faye identity is resolved; the Shandy Wesley Jones link still needs a documented test.

Complete the Matthews family dossier (lead status only until the parallel investigation reports).

Contact Where Is My Land and the Jones family directly (with appropriate care and consent) to learn whether an independent city or county records review has since been opened.

Complete visual verification of the Oct. 22, 1792 Louisa County marriage register entry (DGS 007578998, image 61 of 527).

Complete firsthand analysis of the 1971 Swartz Property deed memo, the 1966–67 UAH easement correspondence, and the 1866–68 Huntsville deed records.

This page will be updated as new documentation is located or as the Jones family's case develops. If you have records, family knowledge, or corrections relevant to this timeline, please get in touch.

← Back to The Argument