Direct evidence

What UAH & Huntsville Knew

This page collects, in one place, the documented record of what the University of Alabama in Huntsville, the UA System Board of Trustees, Madison County, and the City of Huntsville knew — and when — about the former Jones/Avalon plantation land beneath campus and the Willie and Lola Jones homestead on Athens Pike. Every row below is drawn from a named source. Where the record is contested, both sides are shown.

Why this page exists. "Institutional erasure" is easy to assert and hard to prove. This page exists to make the underlying evidence checkable: dates, documents, and direct quotations, laid out as a timeline and an evidence table rather than folded into narrative prose. This material also appears within The Argument section of the home page; it is repeated here as a stand-alone, citable reference.

Direct answer or finding

The record indicates that both UAH and the City of Huntsville/Madison County were direct parties to land transactions on the parcel now disputed by the Willie and Lola Jones family, and that UAH's own newsroom has published the deed and condemnation history for that parcel. The record also indicates the university has taken an official public position — that the Jones family was compensated and that neither the Board of Trustees nor UAH ever acquired the land directly from the family — while the family disputes the acreage figure and alleges the 1958 deed bearing Willie Jones's signature was forged. Additional documentation, specifically the complete original condemnation and payment file, is needed before the acreage and forgery questions can be resolved by an independent party rather than by either side's own account.

Evidence table

Confidence levels: Documented = directly stated in a primary or institutional source below; Disputed = the two named parties give conflicting accounts; Inferential = a reasonable connection drawn between two documented facts, not itself directly stated in a single source.

Date Person(s) / Party Place Record Type Key Detail Source Confidence
1954 Willie Jones; Madison County officials Athens Pike (now Holmes Ave.), Huntsville Condemnation proceeding Willie Jones turns down a $900 offer for a parcel containing the family well; the county condemns the site, declaring the water unfit; compensation is later appealed and raised to $1,250. WHNT News 19, 2023; UAH Athens Pike documents Documented
Oct. 15, 1958 Willie & Lola Mae Jones; W. L. Sanderson Realty Athens Pike, Huntsville Warranty deed Two tracts, including a 2.25-acre parcel, conveyed to a realty company headed by the City of Huntsville's own land-acquisition chief. Willie Jones's surviving children say their father was illiterate, always signed with an "X," and that this signature was forged. UAH Athens Pike documents; WHNT News 19, 2023 Disputed
1962 Sanderson family; Board of Trustees of the University of Alabama; several Jones heirs Athens Pike, Huntsville Deed + condemnation proceeding The Sandersons convey the 2.25-acre tract to the Board of Trustees. A separate condemnation proceeding the same year compensates several Jones heirs, and the Board itself, for fractional interests in the same tract — meaning the Board of Trustees held a documented legal interest in the parcel before UAH was chartered. UAH Athens Pike documents Documented
June 1966 UAH campus planning office UAH campus, Huntsville Topographic survey map A dated campus topographic map shows the university's property boundary already enclosing the stretch of the Athens Pike / Holmes Avenue corridor where the Jones homestead sat — three years before UAH's 1969 founding, and while planning and land-acquisition activity for the campus was actively underway. Personal copy, 1966 UAH topographic map; see The Argument Documented
c. mid-1960s (undated) G. W. Jones and Sons (engineering firm); UAH Board of Trustees correspondence Holmes Avenue, Huntsville Engineering plan-and-profile sheets Undated road-construction plan sheets trace the exact Athens Pike / Holmes Avenue corridor central to the Jones dispute, filed alongside UAH Board of Trustees correspondence — physical, contemporaneous evidence of the infrastructure work the family says displaced them. Project archive, cross-referenced with 1966 topo map above Inferential
1969–present University of Alabama in Huntsville; Willie Jones's descendants UAH campus (Business Administration Building site) Institutional founding / land use UAH is founded in 1969 on land including the former Jones property. The family maintains the true acreage taken was closer to 10–12 acres, against UAH's public record of 2.25 acres — a discrepancy that remains unresolved. Where Is My Land, 2023 Disputed
Nov. 2023 Where Is My Land (national advocacy org); Jones family Huntsville, Alabama Public press statement The family and Where Is My Land publicly announce the claim, describing part of the disputed land as "currently being used as a parking lot" by UAH, and call for reparative justice. Where Is My Land, Nov. 2023 Documented
Apr. 2024 Adolph Jones (grandson of Willie Jones); Huntsville City Council Huntsville, Alabama Public council testimony / news report The family formally asks the city council for an independent review and restitution, stating they know they will not get the land itself back but want accountability. AL.com, Apr. 2024 Documented
Feb. 13, 2025 University of Alabama in Huntsville (official statement) Huntsville, Alabama Institutional public statement UAH states on the record that "public records ... indicate Mr. Jones and his immediate family, with the aid of legal counsel, were compensated for their interests in the property," and that "neither the UA System Board of Trustees nor UAH acquired the property from the Jones family." WHNT News 19, Feb. 2025 Documented (institutional position)

Interpretation

Read end to end, this timeline shows an institution that was a documented legal party to the land — receiving deeds, appearing in condemnation filings, and holding fractional interests years before its own 1969 founding — and that today controls the public narrative about how that land was acquired. That is not, by itself, evidence of wrongdoing; property does routinely change hands through condemnation, realty intermediaries, and heir settlements. What it does establish is that UAH and the Board of Trustees were positioned close enough to these transactions, early enough, that "the university had no direct dealings with the Jones family" is a narrower and more careful claim than "the university's predecessor entities and land-acquisition network had no knowledge of, or connection to, the disputed transfer." The 1966 topographic map and the undated Holmes Avenue engineering sheets matter here specifically because they show planning and infrastructure activity already underway over this exact corridor before or around the disputed period — contemporaneous documentation, not retrospective claim.

This case sits inside the same pattern this project documents at Avalon a century earlier: land and paperwork move cleanly through institutions and the parties who control filing and indexing, while the people losing land are left to reconstruct their own history from family memory, oral testimony, and whatever fragments of the record survive. Sociologically, this is Jeffrey Olick's mnemonic hegemony operating in real time rather than in the archival past: UAH's newsroom can publish "the documents" as an authoritative timeline precisely because it holds the documents, while the family's account of a forged signature and a larger stolen acreage has no equivalent institutional platform. It is also a live instance of what W. E. B. Du Bois called a "Propaganda of History" — not necessarily a fabrication, but a cleaner, institution-favoring account built from the records the institution chose to keep and publish.

Gaps and cautions

  • The forgery allegation is unresolved. No handwriting analysis, court finding, or independent document examination of the 1958 deed signature has been located. The claim that Willie Jones signed with an "X" elsewhere, and could not have signed this deed, comes from family testimony reported by WHNT News 19 — a strong lead, not a proven fact.
  • The acreage discrepancy (2.25 acres vs. 10–12 acres) is unresolved. Both figures come from named, citable sources, but we have not independently verified either against the original survey plats.
  • We have not located the complete original condemnation and payment file — only the excerpted timeline UAH has published and the family's public statements. A full independent review, which the family and Where Is My Land have publicly requested, has not yet occurred as far as this project can document.
  • No documented genealogical link has been established between Willie and Lola Jones and the Avalon-era Jones family (Lewellen Jones, Alexander P. Jones, Columbus Jones, Shandy Wesley Jones). Any shared surname is not, by itself, evidence of a family connection — this remains an open and testable question, not a claim made anywhere on this site.
  • The G. W. Jones and Sons engineering sheets are undated beyond an approximate mid-1960s estimate based on the correspondence they were filed with; an archival date range should be confirmed with the repository before this evidence is treated as more than circumstantial.
  • Next research steps

  • Request the complete 1954 and 1962 Madison County condemnation case files (Madison County Probate Court / Circuit Court records) rather than relying on UAH's excerpted publication of them.
  • Seek an independent forensic or archival handwriting comparison of the 1958 warranty deed signature against other known Willie Jones signatures/marks in the public record.
  • Locate the original 1958 survey plat to check the 2.25-acre figure against the family's 10–12-acre estimate.
  • Confirm the exact date and provenance of the G. W. Jones and Sons Holmes Avenue plan-and-profile sheets with the holding archive.
  • Search Madison County Probate Court deed and will indexes for a documented link (or refutation of a link) between the Willie and Lola Jones household and the Lewellen/Alexander P. Jones family line.
  • Contact Where Is My Land and the Jones family directly (with appropriate care and consent) to learn whether an independent city or county records review has since been opened.
  • This page will be updated as new documentation is located or as the Jones family's case develops. If you have records, family knowledge, or corrections relevant to this timeline, please get in touch.

    ← Back to The Argument